Philly Bans Salary Questions

Philadelphia, well known as this country’s Cradle of Liberty, may soon become known as a Grave of Salary Questions.

According to this Associated Press report, Philadelphia has joined other cities and municipalities that have banned employers from asking potential hires to provide their salary history, a move supporters say is a step toward closing the wage gap between men and women.

(The story notes that similar salary history bans have been introduced in New Jersey, and the city councils of New York City and Pittsburgh as well as the District of Columbia. In November, New York City stopped asking applicants for municipal jobs what they currently earn, and earlier this month Democratic New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed an executive order banning state entities from asking about pay history. Democrat Eleanor Holmes Norton, the District of Columbia’s delegate to Congress, has sponsored similar legislation in Congress.)

Mayor Jim Kenney (Democrat) signed the measure on Monday, and said he’s confident the bill can withstand legal challenges, likely led by Philadelphia-based Comcast.

“I know that Comcast and the business community are committed to ending wage discrimination, and I’m hopeful that moving forward we can have a better partnership on this and other issues of concern to business owners and their employees,” he said. “This doesn’t need to be an either/or argument — what is good for the people of Philadelphia is good for business, too.”

However, the report notes, Comcast and the Chamber of Commerce see the bill as yet another roadblock to Philadelphia-based businesses:

“The wage equity ordinance as written is an overly broad impediment to businesses seeking to grow their workforce in the City of Philadelphia,” Rob Wonderling, president and CEO of the Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce, wrote in an opinion piece to a city business journal this month, adding it “infringes upon an employer’s ability to gain important information during the hiring process.”

Comcast had urged the mayor to veto the bill or face legal challenges, according to a legal memo obtained by The Philadelphia Inquirer earlier this month. The memo said the law would violate employers’ First Amendment rights to ask potential hires about their salary history.

Comcast referred questions to the Chamber of Commerce for AP’s story.